Shape: Eyeko Sport Waterproof Mascara

"YOUR WISH: Staying PowerEyeko Sport Waterproof Mascara

The promise Each swipe evenly deposits three layers on lashes, making them impervious to water, sweat, tears, and other mascara saboteurs.

Did it work? 'Even after a lon day and a hot-yoga class, this still looked exactly the same as it did when I applied it. Removal did require a bit of elbow grease, but waterproof eye-makeup remover did the trick, as did just a dab of coconut oil,' says assistant fashion editor Nicole Morelli."